0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Gallery
  • Contact Us
Mystic Lobster Logo
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Gallery
  • Contact Us
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

Mystic Lobster Online Ordering Menu

145 VALLEY RD
Montclair, NJ 07042
(973) 457-2651
11:30 AM - 8:30 PM
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability
Menu Icon Legend

Lobster Rolls

All of our rolls are served on a warm buttered toasted split top roll. Every roll includes a side of coleslaw and pickle.
Connecticut Lobster 
A classic lobster roll! Tossed in butter served warm. Our most popular roll!
$20.99+
Deep South 
Tossed in Chipotle mayo (mild) , topped with candied (sweet!) jalapeños with a drizzle of jalapeño aioli on top! One of our customers favorites!
$22.99+
Hawaiian 
A delicious combination of Coconut shreds and coconut crème with a mango caviar (mango boboas) topping!
$22.99+
Italian Roll 
Mayo,Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes &a pesto aioli drizzled on top!
$22.99+
King Louis XIII 
Mayo, fresh mozzarella , & prosciutto with truffle aioli drizzled on top
$22.99+
Maine  
A classic mayo and lobster roll!
$20.99+
Middle East Roll 
Shredded coconut and curry aioli
$22.99+
New England  
A classic - mayo, mixed greens, and lemon wedge
$20.99+
The BLT 
Mayo, bacon, tomatoes, lettuce with bacon aioli drizzled on top! A popular specialty roll!
$22.99+
The LBI 
Mayo, tomatoes and avocado!
$22.99+

Specialty

Bacon Main Lobster Bites 
Served warm-lobster wrapped in bacon served with our homemade honey chipotle dipping sauce on the side
$16.99
Surf & Turf Roll 
$26.99+
White Cheddar Lobster Mac & Cheese Lobster 
$20.99+
White Cheddar Mac & Cheese Mignon 
$17.99
White Cheddar Mac & Cheese Chicken 
Please specify buffalo chicken or plain
$14.99+

Tacos!

Border Chicken 
$12.99
Border Lobster 
$20.99
Border Mignon 
$17.99
Coastal Chicken 
$12.99
Coastal Lobster 
$20.99
Coastal Mignon 
$17.99
Southern Heat Chicken 
$12.99
Southern Heat Lobster 
$20.99
Southern Heat Mignon 
$17.99

Kids Menu

Chicken Fingers 
$8.99
White Cheddar Mac & Cheese 
12oz white cheddar Mac
$7.99

Dessert

Key West Lime Pie 
$6.99

Sides

12oz Shrimp and Corn Chowder 
12oz shrimp & corn chowder soup. **LOBSTER BISQUE IS AVAILABLE- please specify in special instructions if you would like lobster bisque.
$10.00
Slaw and Pickle 
2 oz. Coleslaw and a pickle
$1.49
Yukon Gold's 
Whole baby roasted potatoes with choice of seasonings. Please specify your Choice of seasonings: Sea salt Loaded garlic Rosemary & herbs Crab style (old bay)
$4.99

Catering

1/2 Tray Chicken Mac & Cheese 
White cheddar mac & cheese with grilled or crispy chicken. Please specify buffalo style or plain.
$34.99
1/2 Tray Lobster Mac & Cheese 
$69.99
1/2 Tray Mignon Mac & Cheese 
$59.99
10 Chicken Slider Tray 
$39.99
10 Lobster Taco Tray 
$99.99
10 Mignon Slider Tray 
$59.99
20 Chicken Slider Tray  
$79.99
20 Mignon Slider Tray 
$119.99
32oz Lobster Bisque  
$30.00
4 Pieces Key Lime Pie 
$29.99
8 Pieces Key Lime Pie  
$59.99
Full Tray Chicken Mac & Cheese 
White cheddar Mac and cheese with grilled or crispy chicken. Please specify buffalo style or plain.
$69.99
Full Tray Lobster Mac & Cheese 
$139.99
Full Tray Mignon Mac & Cheese 
$119.99
Large Lobster Tray 
Platter will include your choice of 8 classic style lobster rolls, 32 oz soup (lobster bisque or Shrimp & corn), 16oz of coleslaw and pickles. Classic style roll choices; -Maine -New England -Connecticut. Also please specify if you would like your rolls sliced in half or kept whole.
$199.99
Small Lobster Tray 
Platter will include 4 classic style lobster rolls, 16oz soup (lobster bisque or Shrimp & corn), 8oz of coleslaw and pickles. Your choice of any classic style roll; Maine, New England, Or Connecticut. Also please specify if you would like your rolls sliced in half or kept whole.
$99.99

Drinks

Soda Bottle 
$2.99
Water 
$2.00
Your cart is empty.
Accepts Google Pay
Accepts Venmo


  • Visit our Facebook
Powered by Menufy © 2023
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.